The Sourdough School

DIVERSITY BREAD® || PERSONALISED BREAD || BAKING AS LIFESTYLE MEDICINE

BAKE WITH THE HANDS OF AN ARTISAN AND THE MIND OF A CLINICIAN

Set within the walled gardens of Dr Vanessa Kimbell's beautiful Victorian home in rural Northamptonshire, The Sourdough School is home to the Proven Bread Programme, teaching the art and science of nutrition, the gut microbiome and fermentation in bread. We train bakers to produce Diversity Bread® and healthcare professionals to personalise bread through Baking as Lifestyle Medicine. Arrange a conversation today.

WhatsApp: +44(0)7813308301
[email protected]
Follow on Instagram

Book a consultation

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

Student Login

Navigation
  • Workshops
    • Book a Call
    • 2 Day Workshops
    • 3 days Personalised Bread Workshops
    • Tuscan Retreat
    • 12 Week Post Course Support
    • Request a Callback
  • About
    • About The Sourdough School
    • Priority Access: Join the Waiting List
    • Contact Us & FAQ
    • Reviews
    • General FAQ’s about The School
    • Diversity Bread™
    • Where to stay & more
    • Training Bakers & Healthcare Professionals
    • Educational Awards Programme
    • The Team
    • A Social Enterprise
    • Contributors & Guest Tutors
    • What Our Students Say
  • Learn
    • The Diploma – January 2027
    • Request a callback
    • Graduation Recipe Collection
  • What is Proven?
    • Baking as Lifestyle Medicine (BALM)
    • Bread as Preventative Health
    • BALM & Bread in The Blue Zone
    • Proven Bread Documentary
    • Prove it – The Case Studies
    • Proven: Bread Podcast
    • Proven
    • Login
  • Personalised Bread
    • Personalising Bread Using Nutrigenetics
    • Personalisation
    • Personalising Bread

572 - ‘The breeder’s dilemma—yield or nutrition?’. Nature biotechnology. 24(9), pp.1078-1080

Reference Number: 572

Year: 2006

Authors: Morris, C.E. and Sands, D.C.

Link: Link to original paper

Summary

wheat growing in a field

Abstract

Plant breeders, challenged to create more nutritious crops, face seemingly radical choices that constitute a ‘breeder’s dilemma’. In the search for higher yields and lower farming costs, have breeders inadvertently selected for crops with reduced nutritional quality? To create foods that keep pace with our growing understanding of what constitutes healthy diets, plant breeders may need to make a significant shift away from traditional selection criteria. Subsidizing crop nutritional value rather than yield could be an important and economical driver for this shift in perspective.

 
“Solving the breeder’s dilemma requires a radical shift in perspective.”

Significance to the baker

The breeder’s dilemma is the decision faced by plant breeders to grow crops with a higher yield but which are less nutritious, or to grow crops with greater nutritional value but which may come with higher costs. This paper argues that the push for greater levels of production has significantly reduced the quality of the crops and food produced (inc. animal-derived foods). There is growing evidence linking our diets to type-2 diabetes, cardiovascular diseases, and cancers and a shift towards the production of nutritious crops may reduce the risk of developing these diseases. 

Bread, in all its forms, plays a significant role in our diets. By learning about how wheat is produced and the true nutritional value of the flour that we use, we can endeavour to introduce more nutritious grains and ingredients into our baking. Not only will your bakes taste good, but they’ll also be nourishing your body. 

Take a look at our courses at The Sourdough School

Disclaimer

All reasonable care is taken when advising about health aspects of bread, but the information that we share is not intended to take the place of treatment by a qualified medical practitioner. You must seek professional advice if you are in any doubt about any medical condition. Any application of the ideas and information contained on this website is at the reader's sole discretion and risk.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

Email Sign Up

BANT Member
Lifecode GX

Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy
Copyright © 2026 Vanessa Kimbell
Call +44 (0)7813308301 | Email [email protected]
Registered in England & Wales: 08412236
Website by Callia Web