The Sourdough School

BALM – Proven as one of the healthiest approaches to bread in the world.

Based in the walled gardens of Dr. Vanessa Kimbell's beautiful Victorian home in rural Northamptonshire, UK, we tutor individuals and train bakers and healthcare professionals in Baking as Lifestyle Medicine (BALM). Personalising bread to your lifestyle, gut microbiome, and unique genetics for optimal health—tailoring fermentation, fibre, and diversity so that your daily bread becomes the foundation of your health.

+44(0)7813308301
[email protected]
Follow on Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

Student Login

Schedule a Call to Learn More

Bread Delivery Waiting List

Navigation
  • Home
    • About The Sourdough School
    • Contact Us & FAQ
    • Reviews
    • Request a Callback
    • Where to stay & more
    • The Team
    • A Social Enterprise
    • General FAQ’s about The School
    • Contributors & Guest Tutors
    • What Our Students Say
    • Login
  • Courses
    • Workshops
    • Bake For Health Retreat
    • Tuscan Retreat
    • Diploma
    • Priority Access: Join the Waiting List
  • Personalisation
    • Assessments
    • Fresh Bread Subscription
    • Prove it – The Case Studies
  • Our Approach
    • Baking as Lifestyle Medicine (BALM)
    • Personalising Bread
    • 12 Week Student Support Pack
    • Bread as Preventative Health
    • Personalising Bread Using Nutrigenetics
    • Training Bakers & Healthcare Professionals
    • Diversity Bread™
    • BALM & Bread in The Blue Zone
    • Proven: Bread Podcast
  • Admissions
    • Request a callback
    • Location, Opening Hours & Course Days & Times
  • Shop
    • Our Flour and Ingredients
    • Our Books
    • Equipment
    • Flours From Farmers Directory
    • Add Farmer to the Directory

Why does American flour behave differently despite having the same protein content on the bag

Learning Objective

Flour is an essential ingredient in baking and cooking, with varying types and strengths available depending on the desired application. The strength of flour refers to its protein content, which directly influences the development of gluten and the final structure of baked goods. This feature will explore the differences in flour strength between American and UK flour, even when the protein content on the packaging is the same, and will discuss the impact of protein measurement, machinery, and the definition of protein in each country.

Learning Outcome

The differences in flour strength between American and UK flour can be attributed to the methods of protein measurement, the machinery used, and the consideration of protein content in each country. Understanding these differences is crucial for bakers and food manufacturers who wish to produce consistent results across different countries and with varying flour sources.

Learning Objective

Flour is an essential ingredient in baking and cooking, with varying types and strengths available depending on the desired application. The strength of flour refers to its protein content, which directly influences the development of gluten and the final structure of baked goods. This feature will explore the differences in flour strength between American and UK flour, even when the protein content on the packaging is the same, and will discuss the impact of protein measurement, machinery, and the definition of protein in each country.

Working in the bakery in Della Fattoria, California shaping the Rosemary and orange bread.

The different ways that protein is measured and the different machinery in America to the UK means that the flour behaves differently despite having the same protein content indicated on the packaging.

Methods of Protein Measurement

One of the primary reasons for the difference in flour strength between American and UK flour is the method by which protein content is measured. In the United States, the protein content is measured using the Kjeldahl method, which quantifies the nitrogen content of a sample and assumes a constant conversion factor to determine protein content. This method tends to provide higher protein values as it accounts for all nitrogen-containing compounds. In contrast, the United Kingdom utilizes the Dumas method, which measures the total nitrogen content by combustion and results in lower protein values as it accounts for only a portion of the nitrogen-containing compounds. Consequently, American flour appears to have a higher protein content, even when the actual protein values may be similar to UK flour.

Machinery and Measurement Variability

Another factor contributing to the discrepancies in flour strength is the machinery used to measure protein content. The machines employed in the United States and the United Kingdom may have varying levels of accuracy, precision, and calibration, which could result in differences in protein content measurements. In addition, the same type of machinery may not be employed across different facilities within each country, further contributing to the variation in measurements. This variability ultimately leads to differences in the perceived protein content and strength of the flour.

Consideration of Protein Content

Lastly, the definition and consideration of protein content in each country play a significant role in the observed differences in flour strength. The United States tends to focus on the gluten-forming proteins, mainly gliadins and glutenins, as these directly influence the dough’s elasticity and extensibility. In contrast, the United Kingdom considers a broader range of proteins, including non-gluten forming proteins. This difference in the definition of protein content leads to American flour appearing stronger due to the emphasis on gluten-forming proteins.

 

Learning Outcome

The differences in flour strength between American and UK flour can be attributed to the methods of protein measurement, the machinery used, and the consideration of protein content in each country. Understanding these differences is crucial for bakers and food manufacturers who wish to produce consistent results across different countries and with varying flour sources.

Existing Member Login

All reasonable care is taken when advising about health aspects of bread, but the information that we share is not intended to take the place of treatment by a qualified medical practitioner. You must seek professional advice if you are in any doubt about any medical condition. Any application of the ideas and information contained on this website is at the reader's sole discretion and risk.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

Email Sign Up

BANT Member
Lifecode GX

Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy
Copyright © 2025 Vanessa Kimbell
Call +44 (0)7813308301 | Email [email protected]
Registered in England & Wales: 08412236
Website by Callia Web