The Sourdough School

Baking eating and sharing bread to improve physical and mental health

Using a robust evidence-based baking protocol combining the evidence of thousands of years of baking with modern clinical insights, we offer comprehensive training to bakers and healthcare professionals, providing students with the tools to use baking in everyday practice as a wellness intervention.
Follow on Instagram

Soil Association
Our gardens are certified organic.

Baking as Lifestyle Medicine for Bakers and Clinicians

+44(0)7707 480336
[email protected]
Follow on Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

Student Login

Navigation
  • Home
    • Login
  • About us
    • The School
    • Contact Us & FAQ
    • The Team
    • Contributors & Guest Tutors
    • General FAQ’s about The School
    • Be the Change
  • Admissions
    • Courses
    • Course Q&A’s
    • Graduation Week in Tuscany
    • Educational Awards Programme
    • Enrolment
    • Reviews
    • Student Welfare
    • Policies & Compliance
  • The Certificate
    • The Certificate
    • Teaching
    • Teacher Training
  • The Diploma
    • The Diploma
    • Licence to Prescribe BALM
  • BALM
    • Baking as Lifestyle Medicine
    • What is BALM?
    • BALM & Bread in The Blue Zone
    • Case Studies Library
    • BALM Podcasts
  • Shop
    • Books
    • Equipment
    • Ingredients

599 - ‘Health, not weight loss, focused programmes versus conventional weight loss programmes for cardiovascular risk factors: a systematic review and meta-analysis’. Systematic Reviews (BMC). 8 (200)

Reference Number: 599

Year: 2019

Authors: Nazanin Khasteganan, Deborah Lycett, Gill Furze and Andy P. Turner

Link: Link to original paper

Health: Cardiometabolic diseases | Metabolic syndrome | Weight Management

Summary

Background: Obesity is a cardiovascular disease risk factor. Conventional weight loss (CWL) programmes focus on weight loss, however ‘health, not weight loss, focused’ (HNWL) programmes concentrate on improved health and well-being, irrespective of weight loss. What are the differences in CVD risk outcomes between these programmes?

Aim: To conduct a systematic review and meta-analysis to compare the effects of HNWL with CWL programmes on cardiovascular disease risk factors.

Methods: We searched CENTRAL, MEDLINE, EMBASE, PsycINFO, CINAHL, ASSIA, clinical trial registers, commercial websites and reference lists for randomised controlled trials comparing the two programmes (initially searched up to August 2015 and searched updated to 5 April 2019). We used the Mantel-Haneszel fixed-effect model to pool results. Sub-group and sensitivity analyses that accounted for variations in length of follow-up, enhanced programmes and risk of bias dealt with heterogeneity.

Results: Eight randomised controlled trials of 20,242 potential studies were included. Improvements in total cholesterol-HDL ratio (mean difference – 0.21 mmol/L, 95% confidence interval [- 3.91, 3.50]) and weight loss (- 0.28 kg [- 2.00, 1.44]) favoured HNWL compared to CWL programmes in the long term (53-104 week follow-up), whereas improvements in systolic (- 1.14 mmHg, [- 5.84, 3.56]) and diastolic (- 0.15 mmHg, [- 3.64, 3.34]) blood pressure favoured CWL programmes. These differences did not reach statistical significance. Statistically significant improvements in body satisfaction (- 4.30 [- 8.32, – 0.28]) and restrained eating behaviour (- 4.30 [- 6.77, – 1.83]) favoured HNWL over CWL programmes.

Conclusions: We found no long-term significant differences in improved CVD risk factors; however, body satisfaction and restrained eating behaviour improved more with HNWL compared to CWL programmes. Yet firm conclusions cannot be drawn from small studies with high losses to follow-up and data sometimes arising from a single small study.

 

Significance of this study to the baker:

Researchers compared health-focused weight loss programs with conventional weight-focussed programs in this systematic review and meta-study. Though there was no difference in weight loss, a health-focused program increased body satisfaction and reduced restricted eating patterns slightly more than a conventional approach to weight loss.

Qualify in Baking as Lifestyle Medicine

All reasonable care is taken when writing about health aspects of bread, but the information it contains is not intended to take the place of treatment by a qualified medical practitioner. You must seek professional advice if you are in any doubt about any medical condition. Any application of the ideas and information contained on this website is at the reader's sole discretion and risk.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

Email Sign Up

Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy
Copyright © 2023 Vanessa Kimbell
Call +44 (0)1604 881274 | Email [email protected]
Registered in England & Wales: 08412236
Website by Callia Web